• K-12 Online Conference 09

  • Edublog Awards 2009

    The File Cabinet was nominated for an Edublog Award this year. I am honored!

  • Game Classroom

  • Top 50 Educator Innovator Award

    Top 50 Education Innovator Award - Online Colleges
  • Discovery Educator Network
  • Diigo

    diigo education pioneer
  • The future is not some place we are going to but one we are creating. The paths are not to be found, but made, and the activity of making them changes both the maker and the destination. John Schaar American Scholar and Professor
  • Shelfari: What am I reading?

  • Advertisements

‘Tis the Season

No, it isn’t the joyful winter holiday season. Nope, it isn’t the crisp, cool start to football season. Actually, it isn’t even tax season anymore. It’s worse. It’s testing season!

Teachers across the United States are up-ing their anti-stress prescription dosages, buying stock in Red Bull and biting their finger nails to the quick. Students are suffering from proverbial spring fever as the birds are chirping, the sun is shining, and cries of “Play Ball!” fill the air. Yet many of them are also suffering from untold personal pressure, parental pushing, and panic by teachers. Administrators can’t get their hands on enough tutors, test prep materials and number 2 pencils (please, principals, at least splurge for the ones with the good erasers). A swine flu pandemic is sweeping our continent and I would dare to say that our schools are suffering from a much greater, and more detrimental, fate.

Let’s talk about the kids for a minute. Picture an 8 year old. Yes, a freckle faced kid who is just learning to play kid-pitch baseball, a kid who still wears SpiderMan pajamas and carries a security blanket stress-leeroy09481(but not when spending the night with a friend). Now picture that same kid, stomach in knots, doubled over a chair in physical pain over the stress of an 8 passage, 56 question reading test and two days worth of 70 math word problems. Imagine a 10 year old boy, the kind that is “super macho,” having an emotional break down mid-way through a final test in 5th grade that will determine whether he gets to go to middle school or not. Is this age appropriate? Is it measuring knowledge, memorization, stamina or simply stress management?

Now picture the teachers. We don’t sleep. We spend countless hours planning on the best ways to prepare our students for a test that will supposedly measure their learning and our proficiency as teachers. We wrestle internally and externally with the thoughts of our students who have grown 2 grade levels this year under our care, but they still aren’t where they need to be. We turn a blind eye when children who are rationing their school lunches (so they and their siblings will be able to eat something for supper) sneak food out of the cafeteria. We lose sleep wondering what will happen the mornings of testing at the bus stop, in the kitchen, or worse. And most painfully for the pure educator in us, we wage an internal battle between external pressures to prepare students to pass a test and personal beliefs in the best ways to reach and teach children… especially when our livelihoods may be on the line.

This is the gruesome reality of high stakes testing. Children are being taught day in and day out, but are they learning? And what exactly are they learning? They are learning that when you are asked a question about building a fence, hanging wallpaper border or framing a picture, they are really asking about perimeter. They are learning that reading means answering a series of multiple choice questions. They are learning that kids with the “fancy” fraction calculators are taking the same tests as those with the 4 function ones. Kids are learning that education is not about the questions that they ask, but rather the questions that they answer.

Don’t get me wrong. I believe in accountability. I believe in standards. In fact, I champion the idea of high expectations and assuring that all children are given access to achieve their personal best. I just believe that personal best cannot be tested in a secure setting over the course of three days. Becoming a mother has changed me in countless ways (and not just my waistline). Now that my twin boys are in kindergarten, watching their experience in school is altering my own philosophy of teaching and learning. How will I determine if my children have had a successful school year?

  • They still love school.  Nothing will kill the dreams and ambitions of a child faster than a negative experience with school.  If my boys are still excited about coming to school again next year, my greatest battle has been won.
  • They are persistent in solving problems.  I don’t want my kids to get everything easily. I don’t care if they can’t tie their shoes yet, even though most of their classmates can. I am not worried that they still occasionally struggle with coming up with rhyming words. Do my children approach these problems with a strategy of attack and a notion of determination? Are they learning to approach these problems with a variety of strategies?
  • They have an opinion. I know that all parents out there see our children being full of personal opinions, many of which are opposite of our own. Heavens, I know. But, I want my child to challenge the idea of a status quo. I want them to ask questions, make decisions and evaluate information. Hopefully, their teachers are not only tolerating this, but they are encouraging it.
  • They are thirsty. When we give children open access to knowledge and information, they are likes sponges. We get tired of hearing “Why? Why? Why?” when they are toddlers, but that curiosity must be fostered.


If my children walk away from school each year being proficient in these areas, I will be thrilled with their education. Imagine that child. Picture that teacher. I certainly have an entirely different image in my mind of that teaching/learning/testing experience.

Is this possible? Or is it simply something for me to add to my seasonal wishlist? I choose to say “Bah Humbug” to the traditional, high stakes testing season and “Happy New Year” to a new focus on the student as learner, not the student as tester. ‘Tis the Season!

Flickr Photo Credits: “Stress” by Leeroy09481 and “Happy Kids in Squares 3” by carf

6 Responses

  1. Kelly,
    Thank you for being a “voice” for the students (and for their teachers who feel their pain)!

  2. We just finished testing at my school today. I teach at a middle school and had 8th grade students in my testing room. We tested one day last week and two days this week. You could tell today that the students were mentally done with testing (so was their teacher). Accountability and standards are needed in our schools today. But the amount of stress and pressure the accountability part of this equation puts on the students, and teachers, is over the top. This annual ritual of high-stakes testing need to be reevaluated by educational leaders. We need to gauge our effectiveness as teachers more like how you determine if your children were successful instead of raising an score on a test.

  3. Hi. I’m bookmarking item to use next year at Open House. What I’d like to do is share with my parents posts/videos/pics etc. that will help them understand what kind of teacher their child will have this year. I’d like them to understand the philosophies behind the decisions I make that affect their child.

    Can I use this post? Especially the four areas you want your children to be proficient in.


  4. We will defeat the evils of testing. One day we will have a system that utilized the technology we have as a tool for authentic assessment. This assessment can be used for accountability the same way testing is currently being used. Unfortunately it will not be this year or next. For now, we will continue to shift our practices in education (which you are a leader in this area) and at the same time prepare our students for “the test.”

  5. “They have an opinion.”

    That’s my favorite one 😉

  6. Great post cheers, needed a few more pictures though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: